Magical Thinking
Mental Traps & Distortions

Magical Thinking

The subconscious belief that one's thoughts, wishes, or submissive behaviors can magically change the EIP parent, or that a 'healing fantasy' will eventually come true.

Magical thinking, for people recovering from a family run by an emotionally immature parent (EIP), is a protective cognitive distortion. It is the subconscious belief that if you just perform well enough, find the perfect combination of words, or give up enough of your boundaries, you can magically change your parent's personality and get them to show you real, empathetic love.

Where it starts: the healing fantasy

Dr. Lindsay Gibson describes how children of EIPs build a healing fantasy to survive their childhood emotional loneliness. Without a warm, two-way connection with their parents, the child's brain cannot accept the frightening reality that their caretakers are emotionally limited and can't love them safely.

To cope, the child comes up with a magical story:

  • "If I am good and quiet and never make trouble, my mother will stop being sad and angry."
  • "When I grow up, get a prestigious career, and become wealthy, my father will finally see me and tell me he is proud of me."

This healing fantasy is a form of magical thinking. It keeps the child's hope alive by putting the key to their parents' love in their own hands: "If my parents don't love me, it is because I haven't done enough. If I do better, I can fix them."

How magical thinking carries on in adulthood

Adult children often bring this magical thinking into their adult relationships with EIPs, and end up going in exhausting circles:

  • You search for the "magic words". You spend days planning, scripting and rehearsing a conversation, or writing a long letter. You believe the perfect combination of words, clinical terms or emotional explanations will give your parent a sudden "epiphany", so they understand your pain and apologize.
  • You keep performing. You over-function, buy elaborate gifts, host family events, or hide your boundaries to "prove" your loyalty, hoping that this time will be different and they will finally respond with warmth and respect.
  • You appease and comply. You give up your own peace of mind and self-respect to soothe their rages or manufactured crises, in the magical belief that if you keep them happy, they will eventually become safe caretakers.

Letting go of the fantasy

Healing from magical thinking takes a painful but freeing step, radical acceptance:

  • Give up on the magic words, because there are none. EIPs lack the emotional and psychological equipment to understand what goes on inside you. No letter, speech or explanation will ever make them see you.
  • Accept your parent's limits. Grieve the parent you deserved but never had. Let go of the fantasy that they will change, and accept them as they are: emotionally limited people who cannot give what they don't have.
  • Point your magic at yourself. Take the creative energy you spent on trying to save or fix your parent and put it into reparenting yourself. You are the only one who can make your healing fantasy of safety, validation and love come true, by giving it to yourself.